+44 20 7405 9999
Exploring Assisted Dying Pros and Cons

More countries are considering legalizing assisted dying, sparking conversation about its pros and cons. This topic affects overall health and social care delivery as well as the personal experiences of staff and service users. At Advantage Accreditation, we advocate for effective education. To help you understand the pros and cons of legalizing assisted dying, here is a brief guide:

Disclaimer: This information is intended to educate the general public and should not be considered professional advice.

Reader discretion: This guide discusses sensitive topics of death, suffering, and mental health issues which may be distressing for some individuals.

 

What is Assisted Dying?

Assisted dying is the process where people with terminal illnesses or unbearable suffering can ask for help to end their lives. This includes euthanasia and assisted suicide. Different countries have different legal restrictions for assisted dying.

 

Complexities of Assisted Dying

Assisted dying has a profound impact on the experiences of the patient’s loved ones and health and social care workers.

The patient’s loved ones may struggle to balance their wishes to honour the patient’s decisions with their own views. They may feel guilt or anxiety. The decision may cause tension between those who agree and those who disagree with it.

Care staff must also balance several factors. Staff have a responsibility to honour patient autonomy and reduce suffering. However, all people have their own personal beliefs, and ethical guidelines vary greatly. This leads to significant emotional strain for care staff.

 

Pros of Legalising Assisted Dying

Patient Autonomy: Patients have the right to make informed choices and care staff must respect their autonomy. Some believe this extends to life-and-death decisions.

Alleviation of Suffering: Assisted dying aims to relieve pain and suffering and enable a dignified end to life.

Legal Regulation: A legalised, regulated process can ensure appropriate assessments and well-founded decisions. A requirement for counselling for patients, loved ones, and care staff may also reduce distress.

 

Cons of Legalising Assisted Dying

Risk of Coercion: Vulnerable patients might feel pressured to choose assisted dying to reduce the burden on their loved ones or healthcare systems.

Ethical Dilemmas: The opinions of health and social care staff vary. Those who morally disagree with assisted dying may experience conflict between personal beliefs and professional responsibilities.

Potential Misdiagnosis: Misdiagnosis or misunderstanding may lead patients to make premature decisions to end their lives.

We will continue to pay close attention to updates from the UK government on legalising assisted dying. We encourage ongoing discussion and informed decision-making.

 

Here are further resources to learn more: 

Uncategorized